• Filters
  • Sort by:
  • Sweet Onion Herring $8.00

    Free Shipping on Orders over $250

    This sweet and savory herring was inspired by Rav Naftali Tzvi of Ropshitz (1790-1827). Rav Naftali’s sweet demeanor combined with his complex wit are the inspiration for the flavors of this delectable herring.

  • Litfish Lox &Chives $9.00

    Creamy, Smoky, Sweet and Savory this delicious creamy lox mix will be a new favorite of yours from Kiddush to Brunch.


  • Everything Bagel Spice Herring & Lox $8.00

    Free Shipping on Orders over $250

    Rav Yisrael’s unique ability to incorporate many different “flavors” and accept everyone into his Chassidic Court is the inspiration behind this Everything Bagel Spice Herring & Lox.

  • Sweet Black Pepper Herring $8.00

    Free Shipping on Orders over $250

    This fresh and peppery herring was inspired by Rav Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev (Bird-itch-of) (1740-1809).

  • Honey Mustard Sriracha Herring $8.00

    Free Shipping on Orders over $250

    This intensely flavorful herring begins with Canadian Pickled Herring. The kick of the Sriracha balances the sweetness and light sharpness of the honey mustard, producing a delicious kick with a hint of sweetness. The diced onions, add a savory taste to the already appetizing blend presented in this container.

  • Jalapeno Matjes Herring $8.00

    Free Shipping on Orders over $250

    This Matjes based herring is deeply flavorful and fresh. With a striking balance of savor from the onions and a light heat from the Jalapenos the taste is something you have never experienced before. The Jalapeno Matjes is the flagship of The Rebbe’s Choice line of herring.

  • Maple Bourbon Herring $8.00

    The Rebbe’s Choice Maple Bourbon Herring inspired by Rav Elimelech of Lizhensk, author of The Noam Elimelech. Each container is made with real barrel strength bourbon from Kings County Distillery, NYC’s oldest distillery. With a mellow sweetness from the Maple Sugar and a robust ripe vine fruit, wild cherry, dark caramel flavor profile from the Bourbon this delicious herring will become a new favorite of yours. Made with Organic Avocado Oil for that extra touch of something special.

  • Zesty Matjes Herring $8.00

    Free Shipping on Orders over $250

    Rebbe Menachem Mendel of Rimanov (1745-1815) was one of the most influential Chasidic Masters of his time, spreading the teachings of Chassidusthroughout Poland. Rebbe Menachem Mendel’s uplifting nature and zest is the inspiration for this tasty herring.

  • Smokey Zaatar Herring $8.00

    Free Shipping on orders over $250

    This smokey and sweet herring is prepared with zaatar, a blend of sun dried hyssop, salt, sesame seeds and dried sumac. Besides its culinary use Zaatar is also believed to have healing properties. The strong herb flavor is balanced with the natural sweetness and intoxicating aroma of whole cloves.

  • Traditional Cream Sauce Herring $8.00
    At The Rebbe’s Choice where Heimish meets high end™ we know tradition is important. Our mission is to bring you the best and we brought you our Traditional Cream Sauce Herring, this classic flavor made with the highest quality ingredients will transport your taste buds to the shtetl and back. A creamy, sweet and tangy bite make this herring a delicious choice for all your Kiddush needs!
  • Limited
    Litfish Garlic Schmaltz Herring $5.00

    Garlicy and delicious this herring will keep you coming back for more!

    Made with organic Avocado Oil

  • Litfish Spicy Schmaltz Herring $9.00

    This spicy herring melts in your mouth for the ultimate hot herring!

    Made with Organic Avocado Oil

  • Sold Out

    Out of stock

  • Sold Out
    Rosh Hashanah Herring Board $99.00

    Nothing says Shana Tova like a tasty herring board! A delicious way to celebrate the New Year together with family or guests. A delicious assortment of herring and smoked salmon, featuring fresh apples marinated in honey, pomegranate seeds, dates and more!

    • OK & CRC kosher
    • New Bamboo board
    • Includes Organic White Truffle Honey
    • Assortment of fish, vegetables and dried fruits

    Volume discounts available – contact us.

    Out of stock

Close My Cart